|
Historic Preservation Committee
Oral History Interview
- Jack Lee,
17 South Rockaway Drive,
Boonton Township, NJ
- INTERVIEWER:
Ruth Harrison
- DATE OF INTERVIEW:
November 8, 1995
I'm Ruth Harrison and II m interviewing Jack Lee (John
E. Lee) who grew up in Mountain Lakes and was a member of the
government and I'd like particularly to find out some of his
memories of growing up here.
- Let me find out from you something about yourself -- when
and where were you born?
I was born in Wilmette, Illinois, March 25, 1900.
- And when did you come to Mountain Lakes?
I came to Mountain Lakes at the end of the f irst World
War. My father was an architect -- had been in the
service for the year, Naval Department. And had been
switched from Great Lakes Naval Station to Amatol, New
Jersey where they built a munitions plant.
- Now you say your father was an architect, and I think his
name is famous one for Mountain Lakes. What was it?
H. Vernon Lee.
- That's what I thought.
He was a graduate of Purdue University and Chicago Art
Institute in Chicago. ------ board architects in also
New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania.
- And you were about eight when you came here in Mountain
Lakes.
I had my ninth birthday.
- Ninth in Mountain Lakes. Now, did you stay on here after
you went to school -- college, did you stay right on as
a Mountain Lakes resident? Or did you live elsewhere
before you were married and came back here?
No. I didn't quite give the story.
- All right you didn't give the story.
We lived in Mountain Lakes on Howell Road to begin with
and I attended the third grade in the old stone school-
house which was the third the size that it is now. And
we rented that place and my dad had to find another place
which we couldn't find so we spent a summer and part of
a fall in Towaco on the canal in a home there. We
commuted to Mountain Lakes to school -- my older brother
Vernon and I did by train and then we purchased a place
that we perhaps rented -- the old Taylor farm at the end
of Williams Street in Boonton. And we still attended the
Mountain Lakes school from there. I used walk way down
to Main Street and take the trolley to Mountain Lakes to
school.
- Oh, you were a trolley rider.
From Towaco we had taken the train.
- But you did have the chance to ride on the old car.
Oh my, the trolley was the thing in those days.
- And then when you moved into Mountain Lakes you could
walk to school.
Everybody walked to school.
- Yes, yes, of course.
on Main Street. I was down in the village of
school. The switchman put the train.
- Well, I always understood that it was basically in there
for the workmen who were working on the old Hapgood
houses.
Trolley?
- No, the the connection between
Boonton and Denville.
Sure is a lot of history of this place here.
- Well, I think this . . . .
Before and after job the traction company persuaded to
come through Mountain Lakes and they were circling around
in the other side of the Tourne.
- Oh, Hapgood persuaded them to go --
To follow the line of the Morris Canal.
- And so Hapgood was the one who persuaded them to come to
Mountain Lakes --
He wanted them to come through this community.
- Right, right. He was'going to have two types of transportation.
He's got one track that had a switch at one end down
towards I don't know exactly where the stop is -- just
before you reach the Mountain Lakes portion -- there's a
switch out there and there's a switch out by the stone
schoolhouse.
- A switch near the pillars, for instance? The pillars are
near Brackins on the Boulevard. Was it near that?
Yeh -- half ways ---------------
- Towards Powerville.
There were three switches -- one switch out there, switch
up at Lake Drive and another switch out at Rainbow Lakes
connection. Be somewhere the Catholic church is now.
- Well, would that be a switch to enable the cars to stop
or to ....
Two trolleys run but only one track.
- I see.
Between Denville and Boonton and the one that's coming
from Boonton he got to switch. Near Brackin's there was
a box. He turned a key in a box to show he was going
through. He had gotten there first and that would turn a
light on at the Lake Drive one so that he would wait
there until we got through.
- So was there a siding that he could wait on
there or what?
That's what it was.
- It was a siding for him. Isn't that interesting?
It should turn around.
- I didn't understand the fact that that would move. Two
cars could use the same track going in a different
direction.
A switch out there you see so they could tell each other
where they were so that they wouldnl;t hit.
- Well, do you have any special memories about
going to school or what the school was like
while you were here@5
I first went to the school, Curtis was the principal, I
have pictures of him.
- That's great.
You think it was found? I didn't know that.
- Yup, yup.
Only Washington. Those days that was it. Going to
school and meeting your friends in school and so on. The
walk was in by trolley(?) except when it was raining
sometimes Dad would give us a dime to take the trolley.
Everybody went by trolley from Denville, Morristown,
Dover.
- Were you one of the ones that I'd heard about
that when you skated in the bad weather skaters were on the Boulevard to school?
Oh, sure. That Boulevard was the only one that was paved
really. Was some pavement on Briarcliff Road and Lake
Drive but you would be coming ice skating in the wintertime. But in those days they didn't put any salt down
and on the -- all the other roads were dirt and they were
frozen. So that once it snowed you had snow for the
entire winter. Deliveries were made by sleigh, by
Stickle who delivered milk
- Oh, milk -- every day milk,delivery?
Yes. Game for the kids was to get your sled tied behind
the sleigh -- he would only let three or four people do
it and the first one there got it.
- And this was a horse-drawn sleigh then actually.
Of course. The game then was to see who would stick with
the sleigh the longest going out towards Powerville Road
towards Stickle farm.
- But he'd be able with the sleigh to go off on
all of the side roads -- Barton, Hanover,
Melrose and so on. Any of them.
Oh, sure. Mountain Lakes everywhere.
- Well, what other kinds of deliveries did they
have at home? Coming to the house.
Oh, they had -- Mr. Griffith delivered came from Whippany
and he delivered meat and Perry Seraf ino who later on had
the Chrysler agency there in Boonton, used to deliver
kerosene. He also made deliveries for the Tucker store
in Boonton. Actually there was Dixon Brothers and they
delivered ice and coal.
- Oh, I remember ice being delivered to my
house.
The coal was the main way to heat and the kerosene lots
of people used that not only for heating but also for the
kitchen range. Used to be a wagon that came up
from Towaco with vegetables in the summertime.
- That must have been something too. Well, I can remember
ice being left on the porch in the wintertime and you'd
have an inch or so of cream sticking over the top pushing
the top of the bottle out. With the milk, I can remember
that. What did you do for recreation? You say you went
to school and meet all your friends there what kind of
games did you play and well let's start with that.
Oh, lots of recreation by the lakes. Swimming and
fishing in the summertime. And everybody. And you made
.your own dugout.
- Oh, you made a dugout.
Sure. A fun thing. In the winter you had sleighriding
and each would come down which is now Glen Road and
Addington and
- Addington Road?
Yeh. Addington Avenue. That was right at the corner of
the Boulevard. And it was one of the early houses -- was
"E" house -- the letter. And the trolley conductor would
come along there -- he'd holler out "El' house.
- Oh, that was the location.
Sleighriding down you start with at and Crestview Road
we'd go down Mt. Addington which is now North Glen, right
on across the Boulevard and on beyond Hanover Road almost
to Melrose.
- Oh, my.
There was wonderful sleighriding. On Hillcrest you'd go
down to Midvale and Midvale all the way to Intervale
Road. And then Pollard we used to go down Pollard Road
most of the way to, well beyond Rockaway Terrace.
- Well, I can remember my kids doing that when we first
moved to town.
. They'd closed off -- there were many cars to speak of so
with somebody stationed say down at the Boulevard.
- Oh, they'd stop all the cars coming.
They stopped cars, warn the kids so they could ditch the
sleds instead of going across the road. But the adults
used to sleigh too. They had these great big sleighs
where you could, high like a bench with rudders on it,
and there'd be half a dozen or eight people used to
sleighs for grown-ups and they'd go fast down the road.
- Were they flexible flyers? I remember the
flexible flyers
.... flexible flyers all the time. Three people. We just
sold one for a hundred dollars. It wasn't in very good
shape but they wanted to buy my -- my daughter wants us
so we can have lem.
- Oh, sure. We probably have an old flexible
flyer somewhere in the house. I don't remember where. And what in the wintertime --
that's a wonderful thing for all of the summer
-- you say swimming and fishing.
Well, basketball court at the school.
- Over at what is now the Lake Drive School?
The stone schoolhouse. As I said before that was a third
the size it is now when we first came. Then they added
on to it. There was quite a good size piano if you've
ever been in that room in the basement and there was
quite an auditorium on the third floor. That's where the
people that met for a gathering before the borough was
formed. There was a Mountain Lakes Association. And it
was active till they decided to get together to form a
community of their own and it was the Association that
prevailed and took it over from that. Boonton Township
and from Hanover Township. This is made up mostly of
Hanover Township. And when I went to grammar school
there fellows from the borough from all over Hanover
Township -- remember Parsippany and Troy Hills were both
part of Hanover Township. Those are just places -- they
still the names -- people down there if you went to the
Parsippany Presbyterian Church there was one pew that
used to sit with Parsippany people. Another group was
Troy Hills.
- Segregating the two.
Where all the farmers were and the farmer children used
to come up to school with us and remember DeGelleke was
in my class and Jack Crowell -- he had charge of the Vail
Cemetery year 'round. Later on when --
- Was the Vail Cemetery connected with the
Presbyterian Church?
Oh, yeh. I was chairman of the Board of Trustees of the
Presbyterian Church. Later on when they got a little
service we had bought a home in 1942 on Cherry Hill Road,
it's the one house that still exists on Cherry Hill Road.
- Oh-h. Yes.
At that time you couldn't even see Route 46 because there
was hill in between. And Cherry Hill Road wound around.
Was quite a picturesque little road.
- Oh, I remember somebody was trying to drive
through.
. We had a big pond behind us and we had apple trees and
grape arbor and huge garden.
- And you lived there?
We kept chickens.
- That's where you lived.
Well', Kate lived there by herself with my daughter went
in the service. Yes.
- You had interesting -- well, I remember that house on
Cherry Hill with that lovely curve came around and they -- there were orchards in there seems to me that were in
bloom and then the butterfly woman.
People used to swipe our apples. The apples were right
on the road and the pear trees
- That was a beautiful street.
Charlie French lived down there. I knew Charlie French
when he -- he was a Mountain Lakes boy(?) (very soft)
- I don't remember him particularly.
When I was president of the National Iron Bank in, The
First National Bank in Morristown (too soft)
- Oh, Local boys doing local things. Are there
any special events that stand out in your mind
there. Celebrations -- now, of course, you
were there af ter the end of the war and were
there celebrations that people started to
realize that the war maybe was ten years
behind?
Which war are we talking about?
- I'm talking about World War 1.
World War I was too much in everybody's mind at that
stage game. I remember when we first went to the school
there the older fellers used to make believe -- I didn't
realize it was make believe at that time -- but they were
going to hang this feller called by the name of Wheeler,
who was a German fellow.
- Oh.
(Laughter) You could find some of these younger kids to
death -- used to grab one of them and play they were
going to hang him. But Wheeler lived down on Morris
Avenue, lived there for many years. We had Boy Scout
troop. Captain Higgins was the big army man in Mountain
Lakes at that time. I think he was a postman if I'm not
mistaken. And he used to, I remember was there on the
dedication of the -- when they f irst set up the park
there by the Mountain Lakes Club.
- Oh. Memorial Park.
They had troops in the (sof t, soft) near the big Mrs.
the big lecturer -- that's who we could
get -- less we forget (laughter). I forget the wording.
- Oh, yes, yes. Was Memorial Day a big affair here?
It always was. And we had a big do when one of the
French generals came to visit Rev. Macfarland. The Boy
Scout troop met him down at the station, marched with
Macfarland.
- Oh, my. Was there a parade on Memorial Day
too, the way there is now?
No, there was no parade. But the club was always had
activities, swimming meets, canoe tilting meets.,
- Did they do that on the Fourth of July too?
Yeh.
- Did the club play a large part in people I s
lives with the activities early on? Did they
have many other events?
Well, not the expensive -- not one in the twenty miles,
something like that. It did later on when people -- the
old clubhouse burned down. After the new clubhouse -- it
was open more to the general public nowadays. So they
had -- the best beach in Mountain Lakes was the beach on
Wildwood Lake. That was right at the corner -- remember
Bacon Villas house?
- Oh, it was --
Where the fire siren is.
- Oh, not by the Boulevard at all. It was on
the Glen Road area then.
Oh, sure. That was always two words. This is by the
dam.
- Near the dam. I didn't realize that.
Just where Kenilworth Road comes in. Right now the
school, the grammar school and always I thought it was
just a dump. 'Member they'd get rid of the ashes from
old furnaces. And that was hardly ashes. Other type --
it
- I hope it was ashes and nothing toxic.
(laughter) We think about toxic things nowadays. I guess they didn't have many toxic
materials.
------- toxic things
- They didn't have the toxic things to worry
about then.
You asked about sports and all. Maybe's field was a big
item in those days on the Fourth of July. The older men
would get together and play baseball against the children. Maybe's field was where Gyper (?) Road is now.
That was all big farm land. They get in
shape (static). Maybe's was the big white house on
Intervale Road.
- Now on the corner of Yorke?
You know, it's down beyond the big white house.
- Oh, that way.
The other houses, if you got Grimes recital -- he goes
through every house on Intervale Road. (Talking too
softly) -- old ones used to -- you know, when the
borough was formed a lot of people who lived in certain
areas didn't want to be taken into Mountain Lakes.
Mountain Lakes wasn't necessarily an effluent society as
it is today. That time Boonton people and Parsippany-Troy Hills people used to call it Mortgage Lakes.
- Ah-ha. In the depression I remember this was a -- you
know
During the depression you could find not many houses in
Mountain Lakes for five to ten thousand dollars. There
were other fuels too. There was a plant down where Norda
Chemical is now. Plant used to make bakelite. And end
up a ball diamond down there. Used to be down there and
play. We'd play them.
- Was there much inter community -- like with Mountain
Lakes and Parsippany, Mountain Lakes and Boonton,
Mountain Lakes and Denville? A league of that sort?
Oh, yes. There was a school on South Beverwyck Road
I think it's still there. We used to go down there
they had a ball diamond in back of the school. We'd play
them and they'd come up and play us in Maybe's field. A
Makosky boy from Boonton. I remember that name particularly because one of them went on later on to play for
the Yankees. You used to play ball with them where the
Norda plant is. There was another ball diamond in
Boonton Township where the hospital is now.
- Oh, there.
Mountain Lakes kids a great deal used to play in the
playground behind the stone schoolhouse. Touch football
was around there for many years. Every holiday a group
would get together and play. Before that we used to have
baseball teams between Melrose. We played the Boulevards. They'd play the Midvales and so on.
- Now Mountain Lakes is currently recreation
oriented and I would say that it compared with
path. It's always been a --
Oh, I think so. We've always had real good athletes in
town.
- Large families.
When the Community Church was enlarged back in the late
twenties and early thirties Mr. Springsted, I remember he
was the Sunday School teacher, he wanted to make sure
that they had a basketball team. That (too soft) --
- And so they put the church -- an indoor thing
so the church house was made a basketball --
Kids from all over town could play there. Actually,
there were only two churches in Mountain Lakes when we
moved here. And that was true until the Episcopal church
was built I guess in the thirties.
- Well, the Community Church
Christian Science Church
- Oh, the Christian Science Church was there too
at that time. Same place?
People knew it as the Community Church. --
- And that's in the same location it's now.
Oh, no. It was -- you know where the old borough hall
was'? It's not a part -- well, borough hall was the
Christian Science Church.
- Oh, is that right?
Christian Science Church bought across the Boulevard
where they are. They sold it to the --
- They sold their old church for the borough
hall?
And as the borough hall and the fire house was underneath.
- Yes. I remember that when was here.
That was the case for many years.
The Wrights I ived right across from the fire house, where
the Bacons later on lived. Castle was -- they were all
Christian Sciencist.
- Oh, is that right?
The Wrights, the Castles, Thees, the Canadin -- there was
a rift between the Boonton and Mountain Lakes shortly
after Tom Mix became a pro. (?) The borough had sent its
high schools students to Boonton and the Boonton principal at that time, I've forgotten his name, his son's was
in Yale Law School when I was there -- He was fired and
he went to Bound Brook and then because of his being
fired the students had a strike. And the reason for his
firing was the fact that he was taking too much time with
the studies group -- students going to college -- which
comprised a good part of Mountain Lakes students. Cuz
all of Mountain Lakes students were always going to
college. And the strike was led by Fred Castle and
Stirling Wright. And at that time the Board of Education
gave the Mountain Lakes students the right to go back to
Boonton. Then Boonton got out and came back and
Morristown. A large majority of them went to Morristown
except for probably the senior class. And Stirling
Wright and Fred Castle were seniors. So they went back
to Boonton. They both went to West Point. And they both
became generals during the war. Castle Field in California was named after Fred Castle. Was honored because he
ditched a plane after his officer parachuted out to
avoid coming in the army below.
- We heard about his story --
Stirling Wright was an aide-de-camp he had gone in the
cavalry. He was aide-de-camp to Secretary of War
Stimson. And he didn't get over to Europe till later on
much to his disgust because the only way to get promoted
was to be on the front, yo u know. Later on he got there.
He was a general. He Is the one that made a speech at the
Memorial Day services several years ago.
- Well, I don't remember that particular one.
But that's my memory and not his speech.
Well, now, were you aware -- you must have
been about 15 or so when Mountain Lakes became
it's own community. Were you aware of this
change of government? Was there much discussion of it among the kids, for instance?
Oh, yes. Because I mentioned before some of the people
were not pleased with being within the boundary of
Mountain Lakes. For instance, Tom Brackin, his mother
was a Baldwin. And the Baldwins were quite an important
family in Parsippany.
- As in Baldwin Road.
That's right. They've been clients of mine for years.
(laugh) I represented their estate and estate of the
mother -- because of that we learned about it. Actually,
Tom Brackin when he was married and had children and he
had taken over the parents home which was in Mountain
Lakes no he hadn't taken over the and the grandchildren he was actually living there, he bought a home
across the way from it and so his kids could go to
Mountain Lakes school and they were the parents.
- Oh. (laugh) So they weren't too unhappy
about it. Well, now tell me when we were
speaking about that particular year and that
location, didn't your father have something to
do with Yorke Road and the whole development
in there?
He was the architect for Yorke Village.
- Oh, I thought of those nice brick houses.
Later then. Designed them.
- Was it his idea to have the mews concept? Was that his
idea?
I really can't tell you that.
- That wasn't your field, of course. So you
wouldn't have to think about that.
I know he didn't think much of the old Mountain Lakes
houses. In the early days, you've probably seen pictures
of Mountain Lakes houses, where the bearings (?) -- isn't
beautiful the way it is today. No large trees and you
could walk along the Boulevard
- Trees make so much difference then.
You could see the smoke f rom the steam trains as they
went by.
- Oh, my.
But the old homes were -- Dad used to say the only thing
you do with them is to hide them as much as you can with
shrubbery and paint them so that they don't glare at you.
- Well, now that's really interesting because
that's right in line with the craftsman thinking that the first homes(?) were the ones that
should be used on the houses. So that's an
interesting concept.
Well, I'd have to use the chestnut blight. As you know,
the older homes had these chestnut paneling. Our home on
Briarcliff Road had lovely chestnut paneling and beams
overhead were probably covered with chestnut. And stone
fireplaces with a mantelpiece over it all chestnut. And
in the dining room the chestnut way up so that you had a
plate rail all around.
- Right, right.
And it made a lovely home to live in -- very roomy --
- Gracious.
And very pleasant. But as far as from the outside
they're not very handsome to look at and Dad never
thought much of any architecture --
- I think you have to learn to love them. I
think that you have to say this is something
I'm used to and then becoming use to it
Well, he actually worked on the remodeling of a number of
them (end side 1, Tape 1) -- very old. Person
and his daughter married Taft who was
- Oh, that was a bishop house
Later on, Mary and then I was used to just sharing --
like now -- it was very lovely. He did that with a
number of places in Mountain Lakes.
- Change. Did he actually take down the porte
cocheres?
I guess so. (laughter)
- As a general rule.
I'm not when he
- I love the porte cochere now.
I guess Dr. Williamson's --
- What about the dealing with the depression.
Did that have any particular effect on your
life in the depression where they didn't dress
much more somberly or
I got out of high school in @29 --
- Oh, yes.
And Dad always said we were going to high school.
- You mean going to college.
Going to college. My brother Vernon and I were going to
Morristown High School and he went to Princeton. Ralph
Perry the principal was a great one for having students
go to college.
- At Morristown.
At Morristown and so on. Most of the students from
Mountain Lakes went to Morristown went to college.
- Did many of them go to Princeton too?
Oh, a number of them did. James Macfarland. He's my
brother's partner (?) -- (so soft) -- I don't think he
went to high school. Number of the students in my class
and Vernon's class had gone to Morristown Prep Schools to
make sure they got into college.
- Did any of the Lee boys go to Princeton too
along with their dad?
Oh, Danny went to Purdue.
- Oh, he went to Purdue.
He didn't go to Princeton. Dad wanted me to go to
Princeton but I refused. I told him I followed my
brother long enough. He's quite a smart fellow. I hated
to go into a new class and have the teacher say, "Oh,
you're Vernon Lee's brother?" Well, I'm smart as he is.
I said I wasn't going and finally Dad dug enough money up
and he said "if you're not going to go to Princeton what
are you going to do? You want to go to prep school for
a year?" I said, "no,' I don't want to go to school. " Some
of the students were going to American University. So I
called down there and I got into American University.
Went down there for a year. And I came back
and I went back the final year and I stayed out of school
for my mother was very sick and she died when
That's when I worked on a surveying crew in Mountain
Lakes. that's when they were putting in
the roads then. We surveyed,-- a number of crews who
worked f rom time to time so we surveyed the roads
and the bridges [very softly speaking) roads and
it was very helpful in having titles to
Mountain Lakes. I knew how they fudged a lot of the roads
in between the stones and the walls and so on.
- That would have been helpful. Would the
people that are in there do you keep up with
those people? Was there such a community
enough so that you would want to keep up with
the people you grew up with? Did you have
community and a --
Oh, yes. A lot of them came back, living.
- Where did you meet Kate? Was she local at
all?
She went by trolley to Mount Tabor as did I. I met her
in Morristown High School. She was a smart one too. She
was valedictorian of the class. She was three years
behind me. She was out of school for a year [too soft]
-- rheumatic fever.
- Oh, dear. That was a bad one to have.
She went to Smith -- the same principal, Ralph Perry, was
very instrumental in -- she just showed me the other day
she still had some scrapbooks and showed a letter from
Mr. Perry.
- Now tell me when you got back into Mountain Lakes what
was your involvements in government. When did you first
become aware that you might want to be in the government?
Did you attend meetings of any sort and then got appointed to a board or --
Wasn't government as such. Fisher was our
neighbor and he was a lawyer and he took me to court a
couple of times when I was school board. After my
mother died my dad didn't have any money to loan(?),
being an architect of and so I was on my own. I
worked the summer at in the ice house at Morristown,
Shelley's Ice
- In Morristown, not even up here at Fox Lakes.
. Not in those days. This was the manufacturing establishment.
- Oh, manufacturing.
I pulled ice out of the icehouse and then went on the ice
truck. And during the winter I shovelled coal. I used
to tell the fellows in my law practice in Morristown --
I knew all the back doors in Morristown. (laughter)
What I was going to say was my mother died and I wasn't
going to school so I've heard about Wesleyan. So I wrote
to Wesleyan and dad took me up there. My record in
American University wasn't tops and American University
was not an accredited college so they decided to let me
in on probation. I did very well in Wesleyan. Worked
with the professor, worked in the library, at a shoe
repair business and scrubbed floors at the professor's
parties and so on.
- You were able to get through.
I graduated cum laude. I had a distinction in history.
- Oh, isn't that nice.
To protect all(?) the Dutcher prize and it was given by
Arthur Vanderbilt who was '. and was a trustee of
the university. He wanted to meet me. And so when he
came to visit the Professor Dutcher, he invited me over
and Vanderbilt wanted to know what I was going to do. I
said I was going probably to law school. He said, well
that's hardly a radical place, you know. He was
school. I had already obtained a scholarship
at Columbia through the president of Wesleyan. I had
seen an advertisement on the board for a scholarship at
Columbia students and I went into see the
president. He said well you're doing it. I had spent
the whole summer with him in the library he could
certainly write a note. He called the people at the
university scholarship and they said sure. So I took an
exam and got in. And following my visit with Vanderbilt
I went down to New Haven and took a test at Yale. And I
got a scholarship to Yale.
- Oh, my.
I lived with a professor as I said before Professor Banks
at Wesleyan. He was an English professor. And he knew
a prof essor in New York. He taught in New Haven at
Yale. And he got in touch with him and I got a room with
him. So I found out through law school practically done
and I got a job because I worked in the main library at
Wesleyan. I got in touch with the librarian at Yale
University which is a tremendous library and they said
sure, I could have a job there to work with them. This
was while I was going to law school. And the law school
librarian found out that I was working at the Yale
library; he said, how come? Why don't you work in the
law library? So he gave me a job in the law library
(laughter) which was quite special.
- Well, now, speaking of law were you aware of
the various changes in the laws that our local
people were enacting because that was a little
before you were really interested in law?
Well, I knew about the change from the Mountain Lakes
Association which had no authority at all. I had gotten
a grammar school diploma from Morris County but through
Hanover Township.
- Yes, yes. Well, I was thinking of what they
had to do, I think particularly the Board of
Adjustment coming before the Planning Board.
I mean the Board of Adjustment I think was
officially started in 1927. You wouldn't have
been aware of that at the time. Now, 1929
Mountain Lakes was one of the f irst if not the
first Planning Boards that was appointed. And
so they apparently had men who were very
thoughtful calibre serving in the government
and trying to make sure that they were go the
way that they wanted. Were you aware of that
at all? It was a little before your time.
I knew f rom my dad and I knew Mr. Doremus who was the
first mayor. We were fortunate we had a lot of Bell Lab
people and I had been working for years around Mountain
Lakes. I mowed lawn and there weren't many lawns in
Mountain Lakes that went space(?) but I had lawns. And
I -- can't think of her name but one lady I mowed lawns
for got me jobs around town and her husband was a Bell
Labs man and later on they visited Andy in Indiana and I
remember talking about Andy, but Mountain Lakes was made
up of a lot of smart people. They were either professional people that worked in mostly New York or executives and back in the early days 99% of the people lived
in Mountain Lakes, worked in the city and commuted.
- Oh, yes.
My dad was among them.
- That were the days when there were 500 commuters to New York. (laughter)
That was terrific commuting. But they had come out and
set this Gradually a lot of people did at night
too. But it wasn't until some years till the corporation
was started that Mountain Lakes got an influx of local
people living in town and commuting to New York. I know
I knew about the Mountain Lakes type of person they had
that lost on the college grades (too soft)--
- You had a feeling this is a special community.
My dad came here for that reason. He tried to pick
schools.
- In fact, people are still doing that. They
set up a pattern a long time ago.
My dad lived in Ridgewood, Chatham -- we traveled all
over the area in trolleys. My dad went all over the
place looking for where to settle. Mother wanted to go
back to the midwest. The lovely towns and --
- Well, tell me about your connection with the
Fox Lake property -- the acquisition there.
Well, I had been practicing law -- I started out with --
I went to the Vanderbilt in Newark initially and I went
into the service when I was working with Vanderbilt. And
when I got out of the service I always wanted to practice
locally. I then went with Beman, Kelly in Boonton.
Kelly was a state senator and Alan and I had
clerked with him for one year when I was in school. One
summer. And he said that I should go to an office like
Vanderbilt's when he learned that I could go there'and
learn how top offices run. That's what I did. When I
got out of service I went to Price at King and
Rhode(?) he really picked up a phone call to Vanderbilt
and I got a job right away. (laughter)
- What I remember you I don't know whether this
was probably 1947 -- you don't remember this --
but I was at a closing the mortgage at the
house. You were representing whoever we were
buying from.
Who was that?
- I think it was the Klinghorns. When we were
buying, I think that was the one. Or it might
have been later than that when we were buying
from the Eastmans up on Ball Road. I'm not
sure.
The Eastmans, yes I knew them.
- But you were representing the sellers and we
were buying and I said I wanted to have a nofault clause put in that if I wanted to pay
ahead of time I wouldn't have any penalty.
And my lawyer was saying, Oh, that isn't
necessary. And you shook your head at me.
No, definitely not. And I said, I think I
want to insist upon this. And you shook your
head and I said I was very glad that you were
there representing the other people.
We had a statute in those days you could prepay. You had
the right to prepay. They didn't hold you up.
- That was exactly it. And so I was real
pleased you were there and that it was something that you could have an opinion on and
wouldn't mean anything to your clients. But
it meant a lot to me to be able to have that.
And I always appreciated your coming up with
that. And I don't know whether that would
have been in 147 or 156. I don't which particular --
I was doing practically at the --
- I guess maybe it was '48 not 1947.
I was there in '46 which became Schenck, Price and King,
the same year that I got there.
- Well, now an the Fox Hill tract that was about
1952 I think it was. Were you on the Board of
Adjustment at the time?
Gee, I don I t remember when I was named to the Board of
Adjustment.
- Well, you had the thought that we should buy
this -- this property.
Oh, I don't know -- I was always looking out for Mountain
Lakes. Let's see -- we moved back from Cherry Hill Road
to Mountain Lakes and took over the Levernback(?)Road
property from dad and my stepmother in '48 I guess. But
I always intended to come back to Mountain Lakes when I
found a house I wanted to come to. And dad decided to
build his own home I was very happy I cuz he had remodeled
what was the Taylor house and I knew it was in good
shape.
- Yes, Yes. And he built his own home on the corner of
North Briarcliff and the Boulevard, is that it? Where
the Putnams live now?
That's correct.
- That was the house when we moved into town.
Was it?
- Yes. And you had the thought that in looking out for
Mountain Lakes they're acquiring that big piece of land
instead of --
Oh, sure. Well, what happened was this -- I represented
Mountain Lakes Building Supply and they had a little
development over on Parsippany Blvd. and they had formed
a corporation called the Radiant Builders, Inc. And so
I stopped in there frequently with papers for them to
sign. And one day I stopped in there and as I was
leaving Sam Klotz said to me, he said to me, John had a
strange thing happen today, he said, this fellow Oxman
who as you probably know, I said, sure. I had the
corporation. He was going to develop all of Fox Hill
Lakes and owns a good bit of that property. He said he
sold out to Land 01 Lakes Corporation. He said, yes, but
they went broke and he doesn't want to go back in the
development of it. And he stopped by and he said that
since I've been doing a little developing I would like to
think it over. I told him I couldn't do that -- that's
probably too big for me. I couldn't swing that. And I
said, Sam, well, you know the borough of Mountain Lakes
owns that property. And I said this was a prime time for
them to do it. They'll never take it by taxes because
whoever gets hold of the thing before they let it 'go for
taxes you're gonna sell off a lot of the lots which won't
cut them then. I said, tell you what, why don't we try
to get an option on the thing. Oxman did purchase it.
See what kind of a price we can negotiate it and then
we'll approach the borough and see if they won't take it
over. I said you've always wanted property right across
the street from your place Route 46. I said you can tell
them that you want to hold onto that, you'll give them
all the rest of the stuff. You ought to be thankful to
him for giving the opportunity to let you swing it that
way. He said, that's not a bad idea. (laughter)
And so, he called Oxman and the arrangement entered the
city and I was in there and we drew an option to purchase
it and Oxman said to me now, Lee, he said, you know this
is owned by Land 01 Lakes and I've got to foreclose'the
mortgage before I can actually go for this option. So
we've got the condition upon my ability to get title to
that foreclosure. And he said, by the way, about your
hand in the foreclosure, I said, I wouldn't do it myself.
But this fellow in the office does a lot of foreclosures
.I'm sure he'll take it over for me. He said, sure,
that'll be fine. So that's the way the option was done
up. And when the foreclosure was completed Mr. Reid who
handled the office came to me and said, hey, you can
exercise your option now and I said, okay, I'll get in
touch with Mr. Klotz. So I got in touch with Mr. Klotz
next. You ought to go see Mr. Wilcox now and tell him
what you've got here. And explain what you think about
it. Then I said suggested that the borough ought to take
it over and see what he says. Well, he went to Wilcox.
And Wilcox turned him down flat. I said, well, Sam don't
be too discouraged. He knows as well as I do that the
borough will have that property. And he knows as well as
I do that they aren't going to take it for taxes
So you hold onto it and
did you tell him when the option expires? He said, ya,
I think I did but I'm not sure. I said, well you wait a
month or two on that. Then go see him again and tell him
that the option's about to expire and if he wants it he
better latch on to it. Well, that's what Klotz did.
Wilcox still gave him a "no" and he said he'd think about
it. Well, that's when the mayor who happened down the
commuting train and asked the commuters what they thought
about it. He didn't have to take it to the borough
council and all.
- When you say the mayor, that's Dick Wilcox.
Dick Wilcox.
- And up and down the commuters.
And everybody was in favor of it. So he turned tail
right a bit and immediately became his baby.
- Ah, hah.
So, it was just at that time that I had an appendicitis
attack. Was sent to Morristown Hospital just as they
were moving out into the new hospital. I was one of
their last patients.
- Oh, my gosh.
And, so, the f irst I heard about their accepting was I
got a telephone call from Wilcox. He said, you represent
this Radiant Builder, this fellow Klotz. I said, yes I
do. He said, well, I want you to exercise the option.
Well, Dick, you're too late I said. I'm home from the
hospital and I'm not going to be in the office for at
least another week. He said, the option expires in a day
or so. I said, well, I'm sorry. You waited too darn
long. He insisted. So naturally, I got in touch with
Klotz and (soft) and went in there and we got the deal
closed.
- But you gave him a little scare there for a
minute.
Yah. I was worried for both He's always
treated me as -- I was a kid when he was in town. He was
fire chief when I was in school. I was just a little boy
then. He knew as much about Mountain Lakes as I did.
(too soft)
- Well, you certainly had the best interests of
the town.
Well, the thing that surprised me though went to
town and he got approval from Trenton and I guess
Mountain Lakes had the money in their coffers most of it
which they were holding onto for a rainy day. (laugh)
But he got to the closing and I had drawn the deeds just
like our option read and Oxman owned not just property in
Mountain Lakes but he owned about one hundred acres in
Denville Township. It stuck the taste -- quite a
rattlesnake -- we had in Mountain Lakes
and part in Denville Township. And he got to the closing
and he saw that Denville Township -- we're going outside
Mountain Lakes. You have to take that out.
- Oh, Dick said?
Yeh. I thought it was the craziest thing I ever heard
about. I could hardly talk against it because after all,
I did represent Klotz.
- Oh yes, yes.
And he was very happy to be able to retain that property.
From then on he bought a lot of property and then all
adjacent to that property. He sold it all to the Park
Commission.
- Oh, making Tourne Park.
Yeh. And I also represented Steel and all that property
that Steel sold the park. So I had all that stuff.
Either the fellow who bought it for the county, all of
that title.
- Well, Steel owned that stuff that was down
towards in Denville as well as the 16 or 20
acres, whatever it is, up by Crestview?
That's what he owns.
- Oh, that's it.
And Denville -- in back of all the property on Old
Denville Road is stuff that Klotz bought.
- Well, that's very interesting. Well, that was
the most important things for me to get. And
I think I'm going to be running out of the
tape in here and I don't want to do that but
I have a lot of information I'd like to give you for the
historical society.
- Oh, I'm very anxious to get -- well, let me
turn this off and thank you very much. I
think this is going to be very interesting and
I'd like to have that story saved for posterity too. (laughter) [end at 384 - Side B]
Available Oral Histories
|